Cancer Misdiagnosis Lawyers in Cleveland, Ohio April 6, 2017.

"In a Harvard study of malpractice claims in the U.S., cancer was far and away the most misdiagnosed illness, primarily breast and colorectal," CNN reported in 2007. "Study authors attributed this to doctors failing to stick to cancer screening guidelines."

If a doctor misdiagnosed your cancer, attorney Chris Mellino welcomes you to contact our Cleveland office with any questions you may have about filing a claim, including whether you still have time under Ohio’s statute of limitations.

Cancer Symptoms

In a healthy body, older and damaged cells quit dividing and die. Young, healthy cells replace them.

"However, sometimes this orderly process goes wrong," the National Cancer Institute states on its website. "The genetic material (DNA) of a cell can become damaged or changed, producing mutations that affect normal cell growth and division. When this happens, cells do not die when they should and new cells form when the body does not need them. The extra cells may form a mass of tissue called a tumor."

Malignant tumors cause cancer.

According to the American Cancer Society, the disease "can cause almost any sign or symptom." Generally, a patient may:

  • drop 10 pounds without effort (most commonly associated with pancreas, stomach, esophagus, or lung cancer);
  • develop a fever (often indicative of leukemia or lymphoma);
  • feel extremely tired despite getting plenty of rest;
  • feel pain (such as an unending headache, which could indicate a brain tumor, or back pain, which could indicate colon or ovarian cancer);
  • have darkened, yellowed, or reddened skin;
  • itch.

Also, MedicineNet reported October 14, 2010, women should be wary of frequent bloating, pelvic pain, breast or lymph node changes, between-period bleeding, and abdominal pain with concurrent depression.

Cancer Misdiagnosis: Reasons and Statistics

Medical malpractice claims for cancer misdiagnosis have cited the following:

  • a malignant tumor diagnosed as benign (or vice versa);
  • lab results that were misinterpreted;
  • failure to order screenings and tests for at-risk patients;
  • faulty or defective medical equipment, such as mammography machines; and
  • doctors who failed to listen to a patient’s complaints.

"The top reasons," according to a 2013 study by Best Doctors and the National Coalition on Health Care, "were fragmented or missing information across medical information systems (38.5 percent), inadequate pathology diagnostic resources (22 percent), and inadequate genetic/genomic information available at the time of diagnosis (20.3 percent)."

Registered nurse Robin Gray filed a medical malpractice lawsuit after her breast cancer went undiagnosed for 17 months, despite seeking second, third, and even fourth opinions on her screenings, and the fact the 38-year-old woman’s grandmother had died from the disease.

"My story is not uncommon!" she told "At least 10,000 women per year are misdiagnosed with breast cancer and most of these women are young! Physicians commonly misdiagnose young women due to age bias where breast cancer is not expected in a young woman, as the median age for a breast cancer diagnosis is 63 years old." Consequently, she said, doctors neglect to run the tests they should run to determine whether a lump is truly a cyst.

In a press release, Best Doctors Chairman and Chief Executive Officer David Seligman declined to blame indifference or incompetence for a misdiagnosis, per Instead, he stated, "[D]octors today are increasingly time-strapped. Many of them are seeing up to 30 patients a day. They’re working in an overburdened health system with fractured or incomplete medical records. All of these things too often directly impact health outcomes – no matter how dedicated or skilled the physician may be."

BMJ Quality & Safety recently estimated that doctors misdiagnose cancer 28 percent of the time.

Cancer Misdiagnosis Lawsuits in the News

Sometimes, rather than dismiss a symptom as something else, doctors go the other extreme and tell patients they have an untreatable form of cancer when, in fact, their prognosis isn’t as dire. For instance, June 14, 2013, reported that a man had been told he had pancreatic cancer, but he actually had non-Hodgkins lymphoma. Four years later, a jury awarded him $200,000 in damages, even though his lawsuit had only asked for $150,000.

"They understood how devastating this news was," his attorney told reporters.

In 2010, Fierce Healthcare reported that a hospital misdiagnosed an 85-year-old woman’s stomachache as inoperable stomach and lung cancer, since she was too old for chemo. About seven months later, tests revealed that she didn’t have either disease. At this point, however, a nursing home had drugged her with morphine for so long that she’d become delusional, according to her daughter, and her husband left her. A lawyer told the media that he would be filing "a multimillion dollar malpractice suit."

Attorney Chris Mellino’s Cancer Lawsuit Settlements

As the Plain Dealer reported October 15, 1999, a jury awarded Chris Mellino’s client, Rita Radovanic, $4.1 million after Mednet Physicians Inc., owned by University Hospitals Health System, failed to diagnose cancer before it spread. "[She] will probably die of advanced uterine cancer in the next two years because her doctor misread the symptoms," the paper stated.

In another case, 54-year-old Mattie Kellogg died of a blood infection five days after she underwent surgery. "Her doctor failed to diagnose the leukemia she had," Chris and his former partner told reporters. A jury awarded the woman’s family $2.4 million.

To learn more about cancer misdiagnosis lawsuits our Cleveland office has handled, attorney Chris Mellino welcomes you to contact us. You may also download or request Chris’ free, easy-to-read guide to filing a medical malpractice claim in Ohio.