Common Car Accident Injuries and Their Long-Term Effects (Podcast)

Common Car Accident Injuries and Their Long-Term Effects (Podcast)
June 10, 2026

This episode explores common car accident injuries, including those that are difficult to detect such as soft tissue damage and traumatic brain injuries. Calder Mellino explains why symptoms may appear days or weeks later, how to properly document injuries for legal claims, and why consistency in medical reporting is critical. The discussion also covers when to seek specialists, the role of independent medical exams, and how attorneys connect long-term injuries to an accident when pursuing compensation.

John Maher: Hi, I am John Maher and I’m here today with Calder Mellino, a partner with the Mellino Law Firm personal injury law firm in Cleveland, Ohio. Today we’re talking about common car accident injuries and their long-term effects. Welcome, Calder.

Calder Mellino: Thanks for having me.

Frequent Injuries from Auto Accidents

John: Sure. Calder, what are some of the most frequent injuries that you see in auto accidents and which are maybe hardest to quantify?

Calder: Sure. I mean, the most common injuries are a lot of what you’d expect. Back pain with herniated discs or disc bulges, strains, sprains, head injuries whether that be concussions, post-concussive disorder or traumatic brain injury (TBI), as well as your knees, shoulder, wrist injuries. Those are all pretty commonly what a lot of people have experienced.

But the harder ones to show are going to be those that you can’t see with the naked eye or maybe don’t show up as obviously on imaging, what we think of like broken bones show up right on the x-ray, or a lot of bleeding or cuts. Those are things we can see with our own eyes, so what can be harder to show are those strains, sprains that don’t show up on an x-ray, aren’t jumping off the page on you on imaging, or things that can maybe take a couple of days or even weeks to show up, such as head injuries. And for those reasons, that’s why sometimes they’re harder to show or take more to explain to a jury.

How to Document Symptoms After a Car Accident

John: So how should victims document their symptoms? Especially some of these ones that you’re talking about where there might be a delayed onset kind of symptoms, and how do they document that in order to support future claims?

Calder: Sure. Well, I mean, first and foremost, the most important thing is to tell your doctor or any medical professional that you’re seeing that. Tell them everything, even if it’s something that you think is minor or not a big deal, just make sure to get it all out there. That might be a flag for them that you wouldn’t have otherwise known, and it’s just important to be consistent, which I know can sometimes be hard.

You walk in and you fill out the form and then the nurse walks you back to the room and they ask you all the same questions that are just on that form, and then the doctor comes in and it feels like they’re asking the same questions that are on the form that the nurse asked you and you’re like, “we already did this. Why can’t you just read what I already wrote down?”, or “I already told someone else that? Why do I need to tell this third person that?”

But it’s important to be as consistent as possible. Make sure that everything is in every portion of your medical record, because unfortunately it’s going to be picked apart and scrutinized and looked over for discrepancies. Another thing that can be helpful is just jotting down notes, whether that be something like a journal or just something as informal as keeping a notes document on your phone or on a piece of paper in your pocket as you go throughout your day, throughout the week, noting how you’re feeling and how that’s impacting your day, what you can’t do since the accident.

Because otherwise you’re going to have to be thinking back in time and trying to remember all that when you can just pull out this piece of paper that you have ready to go and think back on all those ways that this has impacted your day-to-day life.

John: Right. I mean, sometimes I can’t remember what I had for breakfast this morning, let alone how I was feeling five days ago or something like that.

Calder: That’s right.

Why Do Medical Professionals Re-Ask Questions After an Accident?

John: You brought up a good point too, which is when you go to the emergency room or something and you see the nurse and then another nurse and then a doctor, and they’re all asking kind of the same questions, what’s the reason for that? I know like you said, it might be easy for you to say, well, I already said this, so why should I have to say it again? Are they just trying to make sure that you’re telling them everything and that you’re keeping consistent with your story? What’s the reason behind that questioning?

Calder: Sure. Well, I certainly don’t think they’re testing you making sure you’re consistent. It’s two things. It’s one, yes, they want to make sure they’re covering anything you may not have thought of that didn’t come to mind for you. And two, each medical provider wants to get their own individual history because maybe you say the exact same thing to two different people. They might hear it or interpret it two different ways. And that can be really important to the difference between maybe what a nurse hears and what a physician that’s just had different training hears and might raise a red flag or might make them think of something else.

And so even though the nurse may have heard it or wrote it down, that nurse is writing down their interpretation of what you said versus the doctor hearing it for themselves. Maybe they want to ask a follow up question on that or get some more information. So, that’s why it’s important for each individual medical professional to hear and have that conversation with you, even though you may have just had it five minutes ago with someone else.

John: Right. The nurse might write down, oh, he said he is fine, but then he hears you say that and he’s like, well, you kind of don’t sound like you mean what you’re saying, or something along those lines.

Calder: Correct.

When Do You Need to See a Specialist?

John: When do you get to the point where maybe you need to see a medical specialist, or is there a point where you might even need to seek out an independent medical exam and get somebody else involved, and why would you need that?

Calder: Sure. So yeah, those are two very different things with a specialist, I’d say anytime you really notice either the symptoms persist, or you continue to feel the pain. This isn’t just a bruise or something that needs ice and it’ll go away. It’s really hanging around, I’d say a couple weeks. That’s really when you want to, if you can, get a specialist involved because they treat these conditions day in and day out and know that this is more than maybe just a bump or a bruise.

This could be a serious sprain. This could be a tear that you didn’t realize, or this could be something neurological, it could be a concussion. This could be traumatic brain injury. And especially with those types of pain, that’s stuff that we don’t always consider going to the doctor with. That’s just a headache, that’s brain fog or trouble with memory.

We don’t automatically think, oh, I need to go to the doctor for this. But especially after a traumatic event like a motor vehicle accident, you really need to pay attention to those things. And sometimes maybe a general practitioner wouldn’t flag that a neurologist or another specialist would really order some more testing and take a closer look at it to be sure.

Now an independent medical exam, that’s more in kind of the legal world. That’s something that’s usually requested by the lawyers, whether it be the insurance or sometimes by the plaintiff’s attorney if they feel the insurance isn’t taking your injury seriously, to bring in kind of a third party to do another medical assessment for the insurance to review. Now, some lawyers really throw a fit and don’t like these independent medical exams that the insurance companies do because they’re just a hired gun whose job is to make it seem like you’re fine.

But really I find they’re nothing to be scared of with proper preparation, especially if you’ve been keeping track of how this is affecting you and what issues you’re having, it can really blow up in the insurer’s face when their own hired professional tells them, “yeah, there’s some serious injuries here and I think they need to be compensated for.”

Examples of Hidden Injuries and How they Impact a Settlement

John: Can you give us an example of one of these hidden injuries that maybe surfaced later and then impacted the settlement in the end?

Calder: Yeah, absolutely. So these hidden injuries, again, are things that we can’t see with the naked eye, especially those both neurological at the head or any inflammation, can sometimes take days, even weeks to really develop and realize how serious it is and how debilitating it can be on day-to-day life.

Especially when we’re talking about neurological injuries such as a traumatic brain injury, it’s very common for that to take weeks to really see the onset of symptoms and it can totally turn a case around. These are often cases where you’re in a low impact, low speed accident and go to the emergency room after, get the all clear, nothing. And that type of case in and of itself would have them a much lower value, until weeks later we come to find the traumatic brain injury that’s going to be with you for a long time and be very debilitating and affect your day-to-day life every day. And suddenly the value of that case changes astronomically overnight.

How to Link a Crash to the Long-Term Injuries

John: What’s the process that you go through as an attorney to help to show causation between the crash that happened and one of these long-term injuries to both insurers or maybe juries if it goes to trial?

Calder: Sure. I mean, the two biggest ways we’ve shown were both the circumstances — what are the facts that happened around this — and then the medical records and the medical testimony of the medical provider. So, in circumstances, I mean plain and simple, you weren’t having any pain before, any issues before the accident and after you are.

It’s common sense where that came from and if the insurance wants to say, well, they had some pain or some issues before, how can we say that’s from the accident? Well, if every once in a while, every couple months or so you’re having this issue and now it’s every single day, obviously the car accident had an impact on that and made this much worse and jurors understand that.

John: So, it doesn’t have to be that you never had any issue before, it’s just that the accident made it worse, even if you had some sort of little issues before. I had a little bit of neck pain before, occasionally, but ever since this car accident, now it’s every day I’m living with pain. And that the car accident is the cause of that increase in your pain and difficulty in living.

Calder: That’s right. And that’s incredibly common. I mean, how many of us are walking around with things that bother us, a sore knee or a sore elbow? I played basketball last night, I’m sore today. If I get in a car accident on my way home and I’m sore tomorrow, we can’t blame basketball last night. I mean, we’re all walking around with dealing with bumps and bruises and soreness, but that doesn’t negate or diminish, in any way, the injuries caused by a motor vehicle accident that had nothing to do with anything that came before it.

John: Alright, well that’s really great information, Calder. Thanks again for speaking with me today.

Calder: Thanks so much for having me.

John: And for more information, visit the Mellino Law Firm website at mellinolaw.com or call 440-333-3800.

Share Post :