Hospital Misdiagnosis in Cleveland

Hospital Misdiagnosis in Cleveland
October 26, 2026

In this episode, Chris Mellino from Mellino Law explains the differences among misdiagnosis, delayed diagnosis, and a complete failure to diagnose. He discusses missed testing, overlooked abnormal results, breakdowns in hospital communication, seeking care outside the same hospital system, and how lawyers show that an earlier diagnosis could have changed the outcome.

John Maher: Hi, I’m John Maher. I’m here today with Christopher Mellino, founding attorney of the Mellino Law Firm, a personal injury law firm in Cleveland, Ohio with a focus on medical malpractice. Chris has over 40 years of experience in handling medical malpractice cases, has been involved in several landmark cases in Ohio, and has received verdicts against every hospital system in Cleveland. Today, we’re talking about hospital misdiagnosis in Cleveland, missed tests, delayed diagnosis, and follow-up failures. Welcome, Chris.

Chris Mellino: Hi, John. Good to see you today.

Misdiagnosis vs. Delayed or Failed Diagnosis

John: Yeah, thanks. You too. Chris, what’s the legal difference between a misdiagnosis, a delayed diagnosis, and maybe a complete failure to diagnose?

Chris: Well, that’s an interesting question. I don’t know that anybody’s ever asked me that, and I don’t know that there’s a legal difference between the three, but there’s a court difference between all three of them. And a misdiagnosis case is usually the hardest to win because misdiagnosis implies that the doctor made a mistake. They thought it was one thing and it turned out to be another. The defense said, “Hey, well, in hindsight, well now we know that’s what the person had, but it was reasonable to think they had something else.”

So that’s a misdiagnosis, is when the patient has X, Y, Z symptoms and the doctor diagnoses one disease and is treating them for that disease, and then later on find out the person has a different disease that should have been being treated all along instead of what they’re treating for. That’s a misdiagnosis.

A delayed diagnosis means that there’s no diagnosis made. The person has symptoms of a disease and the doctor either says you’re fine, dismisses the symptoms, and that’s especially big. We do a lot of birth injury in our practice and doctors, obstetricians…it always amazes me that obstetricians, you think they know better, but they always attribute all kinds of things, serious symptoms, to normal conditions of labor.

Most obstetricians are men, so I don’t know if they don’t appreciate what women are going through, but we get a lot of…we’re kind of a case right now where a woman, both of her legs were swollen and purplish, and they first gave her Benadryl, thinking it was an allergy, sent her home, and it turned out they knew she was diabetic, but turned out she was in diabetic ketoacidosis, but they never thought of that.

That’s a complete failure to diagnose, so I jumped to three there, but a delayed diagnosis is where they eventually come up with a diagnosis, but there’s a window of opportunity to treat it. You see, there’s a lot in cancer cases where the person doesn’t get diagnosed for a year, year and a half, and by that time it’s diagnosed, the treatment’s no longer going to cure the patient.

John: Right. It’s moved from stage two to stage four or something like that.

Chris: Yeah, so that’s a delayed diagnosis.

John: Okay.

Chris: Complete failure to diagnose is like the heart attack. If person has chest pain, they don’t do testing, they don’t realize the person have a heart attack, the person dies. So by that time it’s too late to make the diagnosis. So diagnosis never gets made before the patient dies. So those are the three things. So misdiagnosis is they called it the wrong thing. Delayed diagnosis is they eventually come to the right diagnosis, but it’s too late for the treatment to work. And then complete failure is usually when patients pass away by the time they find out what’s wrong with them on autopsy.

Missed Tests and Incomplete Diagnostic Workups

John: Right. What about medical tests that might help a doctor to figure out what is wrong? How can missed tests or incomplete testing or even overlooked symptoms lead to some medical malpractice claims involving Cleveland area hospitals and emergency rooms?

Chris: Well, again, there’s a variety of ways that can happen. The most obvious is the testing’s not done. And we see that all the time where the patient has…a lot of times the doctor, we take their deposition, they’ll say, “Well, the symptoms…”, like somebody has a headache or chest pain. “Well, that could be a symptom for a lot of different things. It’s a common symptom.”

And our answer to that always is, “Well, that’s why you run tests. Doctors aren’t expected to know everything, but that’s why you have tests.” And one of our common themes in cases is it’s always better to test than to guess. So if a doctor tries to make a diagnosis without doing testing, they’re just guessing. An educated guess because they went to medical school, but still, it’s a guess. It’s not a test.

And when there’s objective tests available and they didn’t do them, that’s a strong basis for liability in a medical negligence case. Another big problem, if you have places like the Cleveland Clinic, it’s a very large institution and it’s very specialized. One doctor’s not ordering the test, running the test and getting the results of the test. It’s usually done by different people or they refer patients to a different department or a different doctor to have testing done. And then there’s no communication back between the doctors or the departments.

So a lot of the large institutions like the Cleveland Clinic, you see that a lot in terms of causing medical malpractice claims in that the testing was done, but nobody got the results. And then it turns out it was abnormal, nobody realized it, nobody did any follow-up on it.

Responsibility for Abnormal Test Results

John: Yeah. So that brings up another question, which is when a test is done, or a scan, and it shows an abnormal result, who’s the responsible party for making sure that the patient is informed about that and that they end up receiving appropriate follow-up care?

Chris: Yeah, that’s kind of my pet peeve in medical negligence cases, is there’s not one person that’s responsible. I mean, if you go to Cleveland Clinic or you go to university hospitals, they’re all responsible. They’re all supposed to be working as a team, just like we do at our law firm. We all work on our cases together. We all know what’s going on in our cases and we talk about it. So the same thing should happen in a hospital. And when two doctors or three doctors are working with the same patient, that’s when communication is most important and there should be communication.

So, I mean, to answer your question directly, the doctor that orders the test, he’s responsible for knowing what the results are. And if he doesn’t get the results, then he should follow up on that or he or she should follow up on it and find out what the results were.

But by the same token, the radiologist who read the scan, they’re responsible for notifying the doctor if there’s something serious, the ordering doctor, if it’s something serious, or even telling the patient. But there shouldn’t be…I mean, it’s good for a medical negligence case if there’s finger pointing like that saying, “It’s not my job. It’s his job. Their responsibility. Or her job should…” But the fact of the matter is if they work as a team, like the Cleveland Clinic and University Hospitals, they’re all employed by the same hospital, so they all work for the same employer. They should all be talking to each other.

What to Do When Symptoms Worsen After Discharge

John: What should patients do when they’re discharged from a Cleveland Hospital or emergency room, but then they find that their symptoms are continuing or getting worse?

Chris: Well, I mean, the obvious answer to that is they should go to a different emergency room. But it’s human nature, most people I know anyway, but I think most people, they only go to the emergency room. They think about it for a while and they don’t want to think that it might be as serious as it is. So when they go and the doctors there tell them that there’s nothing wrong or it’s not serious or it’s this condition, and they believe that, they trust that, and they’re somewhat reassured.

So again, it depends on the severity of the symptoms, but anytime it’s a serious thing, and I guess they should trust their own body if they think it’s a serious thing and they do think it’s serious and the doctors in the emergency room didn’t, they might want to try a different…call their own doctor if they have one, or go outside [that hospital system] or whatever. If they went to a University Hospital emergency room, then they should go to a Cleveland Clinic emergency room and go outside of the system because…

John: Right. Just get a second opinion, if you will.

Chris: Yeah. But like I said, outside of the system. We’ve found in our cases, people go to the same providers within the University Hospital systems, they tend to get the same answer. The Cleveland Clinic. Because again, human nature is a Cleveland Clinic doctor is going to pick up a chart. And if he sees this patient’s been seen by another doctor at the Cleveland Clinic, because they all have access through the electronic medical records, they just go on the computer and they can see any care that this patient’s received within that hospital system. So they look and see, okay, this doctor was seen by Dr. So-and-So at the Cleveland Clinic. I’m going to go with what that person said. And they just…

John: Right. So they kind of defer to them.

Chris: They kind of parrot the same thing. Yeah. And I mean, there’s been articles written about once there’s been malpractice by one doctor, it just compounds itself.

John: Right. Because the doctors within the same system tend to just believe that doctor and they don’t want to go against them and say, “Oh, actually that doctor was wrong. I think it’s this other thing.” They tend not to want to do that.

Chris: Exactly right. Yeah.

Proving Earlier Diagnosis Would Have Changed the Outcome

John: Right. How do you prove that maybe an earlier diagnosis would’ve changed the patient’s treatment or prognosis or chance of survival? What’s involved in that process of proving that?

Chris: A lot of times it’s common sense. I mean, if you diagnose a heart attack earlier, you’re probably going to save the person’s life. I mean, there’s so much treatment available for that, for those kinds of things. If it’s a failure to diagnose cancer, most of the cancer treatment survival rates are published in articles. And so it’s kind of a combination of just common sense and articles in the medical literature that pretty much describe what the window of opportunity is to treat various diseases and conditions.

John: Right. The point you brought up before about a cancer patient, it’s fairly clear. If somebody has stage two cancer, we can treat them with chemotherapy or radiation and they have a much better prognosis than if they’re at stage four and maybe they’re unable to. At that point, chemotherapy is not going to do anything for them. Like you said, it’s published literature for that.

Chris: Yes. Right. Exactly.

John: Okay, all right, well, that’s really great information, Chris. Thanks again for speaking with me today.

Chris: My pleasure, John.

John: And for more information, you can visit the Mellino Law Firm website at mellinolaw.com or call 440-333-3800.

Share Post :