For many families, the birth of a child is a joyful and memorable experience. However, complications during delivery can come with unexpected challenges. This can turn joy into concern, especially when the baby is injured and diagnosed with a condition like Klumpke’s Palsy, which can be life-changing for the child and their family.
If you suspect your child was injured due to medical negligence during birth, continue reading to learn about the rights you have as a parent, potential compensation, and legal options.
Understanding Klumpke’s Palsy and Its Causes
Klumpke’s Palsy is a neurological condition caused by damage to the lower brachial plexus nerves. This network of nerves controls movement and sensation in the forearm and hand.
When these nerves are damaged during birth, the child may experience several symptoms, such as:
- Weakness or paralysis in the hand or forearm
- Loss of sensation
- Chronic pain
- Claw hand
- Stiffness
What Causes Klumpke’s Palsy?
Klumpke’s palsy is often caused by errors during delivery, such as:
- Forcefully pulling the baby from the birth canal
- Improper use of delivery tools like a vacuum or forceps
These injuries are often preventable and may be a result of medical negligence. In these cases, parents have the legal right to sue the medical provider(s) responsible for their child’s injuries.
Continue reading to learn about parental legal rights and how a birth injury attorney can help your family seek justice and receive compensation.
What Are the Legal Rights of Parents After Birth Injuries
Birth injuries refer to harm that occurs before, during, or just after birth. If these injuries were caused by negligence, parents have the right to file a lawsuit against the responsible medical provider. However, not every birth injury constitutes a legal claim, it depends on if the injury was preventable or not.
It’s crucial to know the difference between a preventable and unpreventable birth injury. Some injuries can occur naturally during the birthing process, such as the baby’s arm being in an odd position causing nerve damage. These situations are usually not grounds for a lawsuit.
However, when a baby is forcefully twisted, pulled, or delivered using improper techniques, resulting in nerve damage, that may be considered a preventable error. This means the parents may be able to file a lawsuit.
Statute of Limitations
The statute of limitations is the legal timeframe in which someone has to file a lawsuit. In birth injury cases, the child’s parents or legal guardians are the plaintiffs- who are the ones bringing the lawsuit.
In Ohio, parents generally have one year from when the injury occurred to file a birth injury claim. However, if the injury wasn’t discovered right away, the statute may be extended.
The injured individual also has the right to pursue legal action, once they get older. They may file a claim up until 1 year after their 18th birthday.
Being aware of these deadlines is extremely important. Once the statute passes, the courts will refuse to look at the case, even in clearly negligent situations.
Types of Compensation in Klumpke’s Palsy Cases
Parents of children with Klumpke’s Palsy may be able to seek compensation for the emotional, physical, and financial impacts caused by their child’s injuries.
In Ohio, families are typically awarded two types of damages, which are non-economic and economic..
Economic Damages
Economic damages refer to financial losses that occurred due to the injuries. These often include expenses such as:
- Past and future medical bills
- Hospital stays and surgical procedures
- Physical and occupational therapy costs
- Assistive devices or equipment
- Long-term care costs
- Loss of earnings (if a parent leaves work to care for their child)
These damages are calculated using documentation such as medical bills, receipts, and income records.
Non-Economic Damages
Non-economic damages compensate for the intangible losses suffered by the child and family. Common non-economic damages in birth injury cases include:
- Pain and suffering
- Emotional distress
- Loss of enjoyment of life
- Loss of opportunities
Since these damages don’t have a monetary value, courts often use the multiplier method. This method multiplies the economic damages by a number between 1.5-5. The multiplier number is determined by the severity, duration of pain and suffering, and extent of the physical limitations.
What Affects Compensation Amounts?
Compensation amounts in Klumpke’s Palsy cases can vary based on medical and legal factors. While economic damages are calculated based on the financial impact of the injury, other factors play a role in the total compensation awarded.
Other factors that affect compensation amounts include:
- Severity and prognosis. A child with mild Klumpke’s Palsy who is expected to make a full recovery will likely receive lower compensation than a child experiencing permanent nerve damage and lifelong limitations.
- Long-term impact. The extent of the injuries and how it affects the child’s ability to become independent, go to school, or enjoy life.
- Cause of the injury. Compensation may be higher if the injury was a clear case of negligence, such as a doctor ignoring protocols and excessively pulling or twisting the baby from the birth canal. This is viewed differently from where a provider followed all protocols correctly and the injuries still occurred due to preventable complications.
The Legal Process of Filing a Klumpke’s Palsy Lawsuit
Filing a birth injury claim involves several steps, to ensure the facts are clearly established before trying the case.
- Initial Consultation
The process begins when the parents or legal guardians consult an experienced birth injury attorney. They will review the initial evidence, including the medical records, history, and documentation.
- Evaluating the Case
If the attorneys determine that there is sufficient evidence to file a case, they will formally file a lawsuit against the medical providers responsible.
- Discovery Period
Both the plaintiffs and defense begin the discovery period, where they exchange information and evidence to build their cases.
This can include:
- Medical records
- Hospital bills
- Witness testimony
- Expert testimony
- Depositions
During this period, attorneys are working to identify who was at fault and how the injury occurred.
- Expert Witnesses
Medical experts are hired to explain complex medical procedures to support the claim that the injury was caused by preventable errors. Their testimony further establishes that the injury could have been avoided with proper care.
- Settlement or Trial
Most birth injuries are settled outside of court and don’t even make it to trial, allowing families to avoid lengthy trials. However, if a settlement can’t be reached, the case will go to trial, where a judge or jury will determine the outcome.
How Our Birth Injury Attorneys Can Help Your Family
Birth injuries are devastating, especially when they could have been prevented with proper medical care. Our attorneys understand how these injuries can completely turn a family’s life upside down from the financial burden to the mental anguish.
Our firm is dedicated to getting justice for families affected by birth injuries like Klumpke’s Palsy. We have the expertise, medical knowledge, and high attention to detail to pinpoint when and why your baby’s injuries occurred.
If you suspect your baby’s injuries were caused by a medical provider’s negligence, we encourage you to contact our firm today by dialing (440) 333-3800 or filling out our online contact form.